
I made these a while ago and keep forgetting to post the recipe. However I decided not to make them again for a while because they were so good it was hard not to eat them all at once. In fact Fin found it nigh on impossible - and this is a boy with above average will power for a six year old.
After I'd made the lollies and stowed them in the freezer to stay firm, I was upstairs doing something - sorting the laundry maybe - and Fin was playing happily by himself. When I came down Fin looked furtive and I sensed something had occurred of which he anticipated adverse consequences. I didn't need to wonder long because although Fin assured me that nothing was amiss with the sweetest smile ever, his face was covered in toffee. Fin is one of those children who can never eat anything without smearing it somewhere on their person, even a harmless carrot leaves an almost indelible stain around his chops.
'Fin, I'm not going to be angry if you tell me the truth, ok?'
His resolve to hide the truth broke at once like a dry twig and he admitted to consuming four lollipops on the trot, with his tail firmly between his legs.
'They're just too good mummy' he said, using his hands for emphasis, 'I couldn't help myself.....'
Yes they're that good - don't say I didn't warn you.
The original recipe for these came from Elaine Gottschall's book on the SCD diet, Breaking The Vicious Cycle. I used the recipe for vanilla candy and it made toffee that is slightly soft at room temperature. For something that stays crisp leave out the butter - but you won't get that mouth filling buttery taste.....
This makes quite a lot of toffee, so store in a secure cool location. A locked box in the freezer would be my recommendation!

Honey Toffee Lollipops (SCD)
1/4 cup water
1 cup runny honey (or melt set honey and measure it when soft)
1/2 tsp cider vinegar
1 tsp bourbon vanilla extract (or a couple of drops of peppermint or lemon essential oil)
1 dessert spoon butter
Grease a large tray or chopping board (that does not smell of onions) and lay out lolly sticks about 3 inches apart. I used chopped up wooden skewers but you can buy the real thing in cook shops. I think this amount of mixture will make about 20 lollies, maybe...roughly...
Heat water, vinegar and honey in a deep sided saucepan as the mixture will froth up when it boils. Allow it to boil gently, not a rolling boil or you will scorch the honey - until a firm ball forms when you drop some into cold water. To do this, just have a glass by the pan and drip a little in. You should be able to roll the ball between your thumb and forefinger.
Plunge the bottom of the pan into some cold water to stop the mixture from continuing to cook and add the butter and vanilla extract stirring until smooth.
Then spoon one or two spoonfulls of the mixture over each stick, covering the top by about an inch. You want your lollies to be about 2 inches diameter. Any that is left over can be rolled into balls and wrapped in cellophane or you could stir in some chopped nuts first and roll into little logs. I made balls by dropping a small spoonful onto a greased tray and then rolling when it had started to set a little. Or you can pour the rest into a small tray, freeze till hard and break with a hammer and sharp object (not a small persons teeth).
These toffees go soft if you don't keep them cold and they must be in an airtight container or they will pick up the taste of the fridge or freezer. I don't know if it's the naturally humectant quality of honey that does this? Chou, maybe you know? Or maybe you know, gentle unkown reader. If you do, please tell me, I would love to know more about honey.
If you start getting a fuzzy back and humming then you know you've eaten too many of these......
After I'd made the lollies and stowed them in the freezer to stay firm, I was upstairs doing something - sorting the laundry maybe - and Fin was playing happily by himself. When I came down Fin looked furtive and I sensed something had occurred of which he anticipated adverse consequences. I didn't need to wonder long because although Fin assured me that nothing was amiss with the sweetest smile ever, his face was covered in toffee. Fin is one of those children who can never eat anything without smearing it somewhere on their person, even a harmless carrot leaves an almost indelible stain around his chops.
'Fin, I'm not going to be angry if you tell me the truth, ok?'
His resolve to hide the truth broke at once like a dry twig and he admitted to consuming four lollipops on the trot, with his tail firmly between his legs.
'They're just too good mummy' he said, using his hands for emphasis, 'I couldn't help myself.....'
Yes they're that good - don't say I didn't warn you.
The original recipe for these came from Elaine Gottschall's book on the SCD diet, Breaking The Vicious Cycle. I used the recipe for vanilla candy and it made toffee that is slightly soft at room temperature. For something that stays crisp leave out the butter - but you won't get that mouth filling buttery taste.....
This makes quite a lot of toffee, so store in a secure cool location. A locked box in the freezer would be my recommendation!

Honey Toffee Lollipops (SCD)
1/4 cup water
1 cup runny honey (or melt set honey and measure it when soft)
1/2 tsp cider vinegar
1 tsp bourbon vanilla extract (or a couple of drops of peppermint or lemon essential oil)
1 dessert spoon butter
Grease a large tray or chopping board (that does not smell of onions) and lay out lolly sticks about 3 inches apart. I used chopped up wooden skewers but you can buy the real thing in cook shops. I think this amount of mixture will make about 20 lollies, maybe...roughly...
Heat water, vinegar and honey in a deep sided saucepan as the mixture will froth up when it boils. Allow it to boil gently, not a rolling boil or you will scorch the honey - until a firm ball forms when you drop some into cold water. To do this, just have a glass by the pan and drip a little in. You should be able to roll the ball between your thumb and forefinger.
Plunge the bottom of the pan into some cold water to stop the mixture from continuing to cook and add the butter and vanilla extract stirring until smooth.
Then spoon one or two spoonfulls of the mixture over each stick, covering the top by about an inch. You want your lollies to be about 2 inches diameter. Any that is left over can be rolled into balls and wrapped in cellophane or you could stir in some chopped nuts first and roll into little logs. I made balls by dropping a small spoonful onto a greased tray and then rolling when it had started to set a little. Or you can pour the rest into a small tray, freeze till hard and break with a hammer and sharp object (not a small persons teeth).
These toffees go soft if you don't keep them cold and they must be in an airtight container or they will pick up the taste of the fridge or freezer. I don't know if it's the naturally humectant quality of honey that does this? Chou, maybe you know? Or maybe you know, gentle unkown reader. If you do, please tell me, I would love to know more about honey.
If you start getting a fuzzy back and humming then you know you've eaten too many of these......
21 comments:
Crazy....I wouldn't think they'd hold their shape that well, even when cold. Oh hey by the way, you've been awarded and tagged!
Naomi, these look absolutely beautiful and there are no funky ingredients, all natural! great job!
hi... these look really good and i need to make a treat in two hours and don't have time to run to the store, i was just wondering if i could replace the cider vinegar with any other kind of vinegar (i have white and red wine vinegar)
thanks!
you could substitute white wine vinegar for cider vinegar without any problems. Red wine vinegar has too strong a taste.
I hope you got this in time!
x x x
These look so fun!
I can't wait to try these. My son will love them, I'm sure.
That's a great picture, lovely!
The light is perfect, so soft.
I'm sure these were tasty as well.
Yummmmmm! These sound sinfully delicious. So easy to make and fun to eat. Sounds like a perfect way to use up some lolly pop sticks I purchased for a DB challenge.
Natalie @ Gluten A Go Go
I am going to try this, am sure both my boys will love this. The ingredients are so natural, and will be anytime better for them to have this then store bought lollies.
Holy yum! I may have to make these!
Had to post a link to this recipe! I found it this morning and it inspired an entire series of events AND a candied walnut recipe made up on the spot!!
I need recipe for lollipops with rice syrup..... do I use same measurements? as corn syrup?
I'm afraid I've not had any experience with rice syrup - but I assume you could just use the same quantities.
x x x
yum!
I've made simple butter and honey toffee with, you guessed it, just butter and honey. if you simmer it to a certain point, it will actually be as hard as toffee - like the inside of a Skor bar - when it cools. and it will stay that hard.
I wonder if the softness of this recipe could be eliminated by leaving out the vinegar and vanilla?
thanks so much for reminding me of this toffee... I've got a craving now :)
when I was growing up my mom would make pancake syrup with just butter and honey simmering until it thickened (but not thick enough to make toffee :)
These look great! Do you know if I can substitute something non-dairy for the butter...maybe coconut oil? Thanks.
Liberty,
That's great to know - it may be that I didn't cook the toffee for quite long enough as I'm always afraid of burning it. I'd say leaving out the butter is a better way to get it brittle, but it would be interesting to try leaving out the vinegar and vanilla!
Julie,
You could definitely use coconut oil - another vegetable oil might make things a little soft, but I'm not sure. Or you could just leave out the fat completely.
xx x
I have made these lollipops twice for my five year old granddaughter who is on the sc diet. She loved them and is thrilled to be able to have lollipops. I used a candy thermometer the second time I made them and cooked the mixture to 275 degrees and they were perfect.
I am so happy to find this recipe!! I have been looking for a way to make sugar-free candy, that isn't "sugar-free, but full of chemicals." I stopped eating white sugar about a month ago, and it's been difficult satisfying my sweet-tooth! I am definitely making these as a birthday gift to myself.
Do you know the temperature necessary for these? Hard ball or soft crack or even hard crack?
Thanks!!
D,
See the above comment which says to cook to 275 degrees (I assume that's Fahrenheit?).
I would cook to hard ball stage - any higher and you risk burning the honey. If you're looking for something that stays crisp for a while then try making them out of maple syrup.
I wouldn't eat too much cooked honey - it's always best to consume raw - but for the occasional treat these are a lovely thing to make!
x x x
Can you substitute bourbon vanilla for just regular vanilla?
Ashlee,
You could substitute any vanilla you like, but I would stay away from vanilla essence and go for a real extract or even some vanilla seeds scraped from the pod.
x x x
Post a Comment